"Best X for Y" lists: how they shape what ChatGPT recommends

Why "best tools for" articles end up as sources in AI answers, how to find the lists that matter in your category, how to get onto them without paying for a spot, and how to write your own honest comparison.

By Farzad Golestan, Founder of AnswerSeat 8 min read
LIST ARTICLEBest invoicing tools for freelancers1.Paperkite2.Tallyspring3.BookwellAI ANSWER01Paperkite02Tallyspring03BookwellSOURCE: LIST ARTICLEANSWERSEAT.COM / BLOG

Short answer

When ChatGPT, Google's AI features or Claude search the web to answer "what is the best [category] for [audience]", they read pages that already answer that question, and comparison articles and "best of" lists are exactly that. They then show those pages as sources. A brand that appears, with clear reasons, in several independent lists for its category gives the assistant something to work with. A brand that appears in none is easy to leave out. You cannot honestly buy your way in, but you can find the lists that matter, make your facts easy to check and ask to be considered.

Why do "best" lists matter for AI answers?

Think about what an AI assistant needs to answer "What is the best invoicing tool for freelancers?" It needs a set of candidates and a reason for each one. A good list article gives it both: several brands, who each is for, and what sets them apart. It is no surprise that these pages often appear among the sources.

Google describes how its AI Overviews and AI Mode may use a "query fan-out" technique, running several related searches across subtopics before they answer. ChatGPT search and Claude with web search also search first and then cite what they used. For a "best" question, the related searches lead straight to the articles that rank and compare options.

Without web search, an assistant answers from what it learned in training. No one outside the AI companies can see exactly how that works, but a brand that is described clearly on many independent pages has far more chances to be learned than one that is barely mentioned.

Check this for yourself: ask your top buyer question with web search on and open the sources. Count how many of them are list or comparison articles.

How do you find the lists that matter in your category?

  1. Write the "best" questions your buyers ask, in their words: "best [category] for [audience]", "best [category] for [use case]", "[competitor] alternatives".
  2. Ask each question in ChatGPT with search on, in Google (AI Overview or AI Mode) and in Claude with web search on. Note every list or comparison article among the sources.
  3. Search the same questions in Google and note the list articles on the first page. Many lists that rank also end up as AI sources.
  4. For each article, record who publishes it, when it was last updated, whether you are on it, and how to contact the author.

Which lists are worth your time?

Not every list carries the same weight, for buyers or for AI assistants. A rough guide:

Type of listHow to recognise itWorth pursuing?
Independent review with real testingNamed author, explained method, screenshots, pros and cons, a recent update dateYes, your top priority
Trade association or community resourcePublished by a body or group your buyers trustYes
Affiliate list with real reviewsDiscloses commissions, but shows hands-on testingOften, if it is kept up to date
Competitor's "best tools" postWritten by a vendor that ranks itself firstRarely. Answer it with your own honest comparison instead
Pay-to-be-listed pagesEvery listing paid, little or no evaluationLow, unless your source map shows AI assistants cite it
Mass-produced fillerGeneric text, no author, no testing, many near-identical pagesNo

How do you get onto a list without paying for a spot?

Editors want lists that help their readers and stay accurate. Make it easy for them:

  1. Make your facts easy to check. One clear sentence on your homepage about what you are and who you are for (see how to write it), public pricing, and a short page with screenshots and key facts for reviewers.
  2. Offer a free test account, so the reviewer can try the product instead of copying your marketing.
  3. Send a short, specific email. Explain which readers you are a good fit for, not why you are "the best".
  4. Correct errors politely. If a list describes you wrongly or uses old prices, send the correct facts with a source.
  5. Follow up when the article is updated. Many lists show an update date, and editors often add new options then.
A pitch an editor can act on in one read: specific, honest, easy to say no to.
Subject: A tool for [audience] for your [article title]

Hi [name], I read your list of [category] for [audience], updated [month]. We make [brand], a [category] for [audience] that [one checkable difference]. If you update the list, I can give you a free account to test it, plus screenshots and current pricing. If it is not a fit for your readers, no problem. [Your name], [role]

What about paying for a place on a list?

Sponsored placements exist and can be legitimate, but treat them as advertising, not as an independent recommendation:

  • Google asks site owners to mark links that are advertisements or paid placements with rel="sponsored", and its spam policies list buying or selling links for ranking purposes as link spam.
  • In the US, the FTC says a review can be deceptive if buying an ad influences what is reviewed, what is said about it or where it is placed. Other countries have similar advertising rules.
  • Never buy reviews or fake testimonials. Besides platform bans, the FTC rule on consumer reviews bans fake reviews outright.

If you sponsor a list, make sure the publisher marks it clearly. Then judge it like any ad, by the buyers it brings, not by whether it changes AI answers.

Should you publish your own "best X" list?

Yes, if you do it honestly. A comparison on your own site can be a useful source, as long as it helps a buyer decide. Google's guidance on reviews is a good checklist:

  • Explain how you compared: the criteria, what you tested and when.
  • Show evidence of your own experience, such as screenshots or measurements.
  • Cover benefits and drawbacks, including your own.
  • Say which option is best for which kind of buyer, and why, even when the answer is a competitor.
  • Give each listed option enough real detail to stand on its own, and keep prices and dates current.

A page that puts you first on every line and rates every competitor badly convinces no one, person or machine. You can see how we approached it on our comparison page, which points to other tools for jobs we do not do.

How do you know if it is working?

Ask the same "best" questions every month, with web search on, and compare the answers and their sources with last month. You are looking for three changes: you appear among the sources, you are named in the answer, and the description of you is accurate.

For a faster check, run a free audit. It asks ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude the questions your buyers ask, checks the live answers in ChatGPT search and Google's AI features, and shows who gets named instead of you. Lists are one type of source. For the rest, see how to get listed on the sites AI assistants cite.

Questions people also ask

Does my position on a list matter?

No one outside the AI companies knows exactly how position is weighed. Being included, with an accurate description of who you are for, is the part you can influence, and it matters to human readers too.

How many lists do I need to be on?

There is no known number. Start with the lists that already appear as sources for your buyers' questions. Two or three of those are worth more than twenty that no one cites.

Do AI assistants trust affiliate lists?

They may cite them like any other page. What makes a list more useful, for readers and as a source, is real testing, a clear method and a recent update, whether or not it earns commissions.

Does this work for local businesses?

The idea is the same, but the lists are local guides, map listings and review sites. Google also says a complete Google Business Profile can help a local business appear in its AI responses.

See which brands ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude name instead of you.

The free audit runs buyer questions for you and hands you a prioritised list of fixes.

Run my free audit

No credit card. Results in 3 to 5 minutes.

Sources

Comments

No comments yet. Questions and experiences are welcome.

Sign in to comment

Comments are open to AnswerSeat members. We email you a one-click sign-in link; new here, the same link creates your free account.

By continuing you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Keep reading